| | | WL wins toss, will receive. Shepherd defends South Goal |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | SHEP ball on SHEP30. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 65 yards to the WLU5, Marcus Brown return 15 yards to the WLU20 (Tim Durrant;Kenny Williams). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Brandon Carver for 80 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:42. |
| | | Jeff Hoak kick attempt failed (blocked), returned by Chris Patton - no score (blocked by Robert Hayes). |
| | | West Liberty 6, Shepherd University 0 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 80 yards, TOP 00:18 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 56 yards to the SHEP14, Wm. McKenzie return 15 yards to the SHEP29 (Rod White). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep29 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:38. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep29 | PENALTY SHEP delay of game 5 yards to the SHEP24. |
| Shep | 1-15 | at Shep24 | PENALTY SHEP false start 5 yards to the SHEP19. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep19 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Justin Ford for 17 yards to the SHEP36 (L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 2-3 | at Shep36 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Neal Hardie for 10 yards to the SHEP46, 1ST DOWN SHEP (L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Justin Ford. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep46 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Neal Hardie for 3 yards to the SHEP49. |
| Shep | 3-7 | at Shep49 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete. |
| Shep | 4-7 | at Shep49 | Troy McNeill punt 41 yards to the WLU10, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:00 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 12:38. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Hak. Cartwright for 2 yards to the WLU12 (Dom Dixon). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Wlu12 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Marvin Murray for 10 yards to the WLU22, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu22 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Tristen Devers for 11 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Tristen Devers for 6 yards to the WLU39 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Wlu39 | Jimmy Burress rush for 7 yards to the WLU46, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu46 | L.D. Crow sacked for loss of 12 yards to the WLU34 (Howard Jones). |
| Wlu | 2-22 | at Wlu34 | L.D. Crow pass intercepted by Elijah Davis at the WLU35, Elijah Davis return 35 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:25. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 24 yards, TOP 03:13 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 7, West Liberty 6 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 68 yards to the WLU2, Justin Black return 33 yards to the WLU35 (Kenny Williams). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 09:18. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Marvin Murray for 6 yards to the WLU41 (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Wlu41 | Brandon Davis rush for no gain to the WLU41 (Leons Kabongo). |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Wlu41 | Scott Victorio rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU40 (Leons Kabongo). |
| Wlu | 4-5 | at Wlu40 | Griffin Yocum punt 38 yards to the SHEP22, Cor. Washington return -5 yards to the SHEP17 (D. Whittlesey). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:20. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | PENALTY SHEP false start 5 yards to the SHEP12. |
| Shep | 1-15 | at Shep12 | Bobby Cooper pass intercepted by Carl Hayles at the SHEP14, Carl Hayles return 0 yards to the SHEP14. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep14 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 07:13. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep14 | Jimmy Burress rush for loss of 5 yards to the SHEP19 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 2-15 | at Shep19 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Kyle Agustin for 1 yard to the SHEP18 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 3-14 | at Shep18 | L.D. Crow pass complete to B. Schroeder for 17 yards to the SHEP1, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep01 | L.D. Crow rush for no gain to the SHEP1 (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep01 | L.D. Crow rush for 1 yard to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:34. |
| | | Jeff Hoak kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Howard Jones). |
| | | West Liberty 12, Shepherd University 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:39 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 50 yards to the SHEP20, Neal Hardie return 35 yards to the WLU45 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 04:27. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Michael Haynes rush for 7 yards to the WLU38 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-3 | at Wlu38 | PENALTY SHEP false start 5 yards to the WLU43. |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu43 | Michael Haynes rush for 4 yards to the WLU39 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Wlu39 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to John Frick for 6 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Kevin Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU31 (L. Redding). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu31 | Bobby Cooper rush for 3 yards to the WLU28 (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu28 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Neal Hardie for 8 yards to the WLU20, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Michael Haynes rush for 3 yards to the WLU17 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu17 | Michael Haynes rush for 3 yards to the WLU14 (D. Whittlesey). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 31 yards, TOP 05:11 |
| | | West Liberty 12, Shepherd University 7 |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Wlu14 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Wlu14 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Wm. McKenzie for loss of 3 yards to the WLU17 (L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 4-7 | at Wlu17 | Eric Dobratz field goal attempt from 34 GOOD, clock 14:16. |
| | | West Liberty 12, Shepherd University 10 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 28 yards, TOP 05:11 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 65 yards to the WLU5, Brandon Brown return 17 yards to the WLU22 (Deon Jones), PENALTY WLU holding 11 yards to the WLU11, 1st and 10, WLU ball on WLU11. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu11 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 14:14. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu11 | PENALTY WLU pass interference 5 yards to the WLU6. |
| Wlu | 1-15 | at Wlu06 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Tyler Tucci for 2 yards to the WLU8 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 2-13 | at Wlu08 | TEAM rush for loss of 8 yards to the WLU0, TEAM safety, clock 13:21. |
| | | West Liberty 12, Shepherd University 12 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 00:53 |
| | | Payne Shanafelt kickoff 35 yards to the SHEP45, out-of-bounds, SHEP ball on WLU45. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:19. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Kenny Williams rush for 35 yards to the WLU10, 1ST DOWN SHEP (D. Whittlesey). |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu10 | PENALTY SHEP holding 10 yards to the WLU20. |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu20 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to A. Weisenmiller for 5 yards to the WLU15 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 2-G | at Wlu15 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Kenny Williams for 8 yards to the WLU7 (D. Whittlesey). |
| Shep | 3-G | at Wlu07 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to A. Weisenmiller. |
| Shep | 4-G | at Wlu07 | Eric Dobratz field goal attempt from 24 GOOD, clock 10:50. |
| | | Shepherd University 15, West Liberty 12 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 38 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 64 yards to the WLU6, Tristen Devers return 29 yards to the WLU35 (Vince Drzal), PENALTY SHEP personal foul 15 yards to the 50 yardline, 1st and 10, WLU ball on 50 yardline. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu50 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 10:45. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu50 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Brandon Carver. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu50 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Brandon Carver. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Wlu50 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 4-10 | at Wlu50 | Timeout West Liberty, clock 10:34. |
| Wlu | 4-10 | at Wlu50 | Griffin Yocum punt 48 yards to the SHEP2, Cor. Washington return 2 yards to the SHEP4 (Brandon Brown). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:24 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep04 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 10:21. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep04 | Michael Haynes rush for 2 yards to the SHEP6 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep06 | Michael Haynes rush for 4 yards to the SHEP10. |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Shep10 | Bobby Cooper sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHEP6 (Alec Wood), fumble by Bobby Cooper recovered by WLU Nick Augustyn at SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:01. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by TEAM). |
| | | West Liberty 18, Shepherd University 15 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 51 yards to the SHEP19, Wm. McKenzie return 24 yards to the SHEP43. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep43 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 08:54. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep43 | Kenny Williams rush for 8 yards to the WLU49 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-2 | at Wlu49 | Kenny Williams rush for 16 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU31 (L. Redding). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu31 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Kenny Williams for 23 yards to the WLU8, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Quinton Sifford;Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu08 | Kenny Williams rush for 5 yards to the WLU3 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-G | at Wlu03 | Kenny Williams rush for 3 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:06. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 22, West Liberty 18 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 57 yards, TOP 02:48 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 70 yards to the WLU0, Justin Black return 19 yards to the WLU19 (Parris Baxter). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 06:01. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | Brandon Davis rush for no gain to the WLU19 (Dom Dixon). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu19 | L.D. Crow sacked for loss of 10 yards to the WLU9 (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 3-20 | at Wlu09 | Brandon Davis rush for 9 yards to the WLU18 (Dom Dixon). |
| Wlu | 4-11 | at Wlu18 | PENALTY SHEP roughing the kicker 15 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Marvin Murray. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu33 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Brandon Carver for 30 yards to the SHEP37, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep37 | PENALTY WLU holding 10 yards to the SHEP47. |
| Wlu | 1-20 | at Shep47 | L.D. Crow sacked for loss of 8 yards to the WLU45 (Howard Jones). |
| Wlu | 2-28 | at Wlu45 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 03:03. |
| Wlu | 2-28 | at Wlu45 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Brandon Carver (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 3-28 | at Wlu45 | L.D. Crow pass complete to B. Schroeder for 10 yards to the SHEP45 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 4-18 | at Shep45 | Griffin Yocum punt 45 yards to the SHEP0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 36 yards, TOP 03:52 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:09. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | PENALTY SHEP holding 10 yards to the SHEP10. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep10 | Michael Haynes rush for 9 yards to the SHEP19 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-11 | at Shep19 | Michael Haynes rush for no gain to the SHEP19 (Tevita Fehoko). |
| Shep | 3-11 | at Shep19 | Timeout West Liberty, clock 01:18. |
| Shep | 3-11 | at Shep19 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Justin Ford for 7 yards to the SHEP26 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 4-4 | at Shep26 | Troy McNeill punt 30 yards to the WLU44, fair catch by Hak. Cartwright. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 01:05. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | PENALTY SHEP pass interference 13 yards to the SHEP43, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep43 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Marvin Murray for 12 yards to the SHEP31, 1ST DOWN WLU (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep31 | Timeout West Liberty, clock 00:54. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep31 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to B. Schroeder. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep31 | L.D. Crow sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHEP35 (Jon Heavner). |
| Wlu | 3-14 | at Shep35 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Marvin Murray. |
| Wlu | 4-14 | at Shep35 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to B. Schroeder. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 21 yards, TOP 00:42 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep35 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:23. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep35 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Michael Haynes (L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep35 | Michael Haynes rush for 3 yards to the SHEP38 (Kyle Agustin;L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 3-7 | at Shep38 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| | | Shepherd University 22, West Liberty 18 |
| Shep | 3-7 | at Shep38 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, WLU ball on WLU30. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 41 yards to the SHEP29, Michael Haynes return 3 yards to the SHEP32 (Rod White). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep32 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:57. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep32 | Michael Haynes rush for 11 yards to the SHEP43, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep43 | Michael Haynes rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHEP41 (Lukas Turley). |
| Shep | 2-12 | at Shep41 | Michael Haynes rush for 16 yards to the WLU43, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Tevita Fehoko;Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu43 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU41 (Tevita Fehoko). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu41 | Neal Hardie rush for no gain to the WLU41 (Isaac Omaits). |
| Shep | 3-8 | at Wlu41 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Robert Byrd for 8 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Brandon Thigpen). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Kenny Williams rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU35 (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 2-12 | at Wlu35 | Bobby Cooper rush for 25 yards to the WLU10, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu10 | Kenny Williams rush for 8 yards to the WLU2 (Isaac Omaits). |
| Shep | 2-G | at Wlu02 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:50. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 29, West Liberty 18 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 68 yards, TOP 05:20 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 60 yards to the WLU10, Justin Black return 90 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:37. |
| | | L.D. Crow pass attempt failed. |
| | | Shepherd University 29, West Liberty 24 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 53 yards to the SHEP17, Wm. McKenzie return 21 yards to the SHEP38 (Josh White). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep38 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:31. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep38 | Michael Haynes rush for 6 yards to the SHEP44 (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep44 | Michael Haynes rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti;Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep50 | Michael Haynes rush for 6 yards to the WLU44 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Wlu44 | Kenny Williams rush for 20 yards to the WLU24, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu24 | Kenny Williams rush for 11 yards to the WLU13, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu13 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Nik Norrell for 3 yards to the WLU10 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu10 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU8 (Lukas Turley). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu08 | Kenny Williams rush for 3 yards to the WLU5 (Kyle Agustin;Nate Maleski). |
| Shep | 4-2 | at Wlu05 | Kenny Williams rush for 3 yards to the WLU2, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu02 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:03. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 36, West Liberty 24 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 62 yards, TOP 05:28 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 70 yards to the WLU0, touchback. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 04:03. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Tyler Tucci for 15 yards to the WLU35, 1ST DOWN WLU (Maurice Perry). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Brandon Carver (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu35 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Jimmy Burress for loss of 3 yards to the WLU32 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 3-13 | at Wlu32 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete to Brandon Carver. |
| Wlu | 4-13 | at Wlu32 | Griffin Yocum punt 38 yards to the SHEP30, Cor. Washington return 14 yards to the SHEP44 (Brandon Thigpen). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 12 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:31. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | PENALTY SHEP holding 7 yards to the SHEP37. |
| Shep | 1-17 | at Shep37 | Michael Haynes rush for no gain to the SHEP37 (Nick Augustyn). |
| Shep | 2-17 | at Shep37 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 01:44. |
| Shep | 2-17 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Neal Hardie for 7 yards to the SHEP44 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Shep44 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Justin Ford. |
| Shep | 4-10 | at Shep44 | Troy McNeill punt 28 yards to the WLU28, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:44 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 00:47. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Brandon Davis rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU26 (Tim Durrant). |
| Wlu | 2-12 | at Wlu26 | L.D. Crow rush for 5 yards to the WLU31. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| | | Shepherd University 36, West Liberty 24 |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Wlu31 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Wlu31 | L.D. Crow pass complete to Hak. Cartwright for 5 yards to the WLU36 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 4-2 | at Wlu36 | PENALTY WLU delay of game 5 yards to the WLU31. |
| Wlu | 4-7 | at Wlu31 | Griffin Yocum punt 61 yards to the SHEP8, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep08 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:37. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep08 | Kenny Williams rush for 3 yards to the SHEP11 (L. Robinson). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Shep11 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the SHEP13 (Nick Augustyn). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Shep13 | Bobby Cooper rush for 6 yards to the SHEP19, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Lukas Turley). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep19 | Kenny Williams rush for 6 yards to the SHEP25 (T.J. Lesniewski). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep25 | Kenny Williams rush for 2 yards to the SHEP27 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep27 | Kenny Williams rush for 18 yards to the SHEP45, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep45 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Nik Norrell for 7 yards to the WLU48 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-3 | at Wlu48 | Michael Haynes rush for 4 yards to the WLU44, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Nate Maleski). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | Michael Haynes rush for 5 yards to the WLU39 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu39 | 1st and 10. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu39 | PENALTY WLU pass interference 23 yards to the WLU16, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu16 | Kenny Williams rush for 3 yards to the WLU13 (Ryan Hughes). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu13 | Kenny Williams rush for 1 yard to the WLU12 (Nate Maleski). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Wlu12 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Nik Norrell for 12 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:13. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 43, West Liberty 24 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 92 yards, TOP 07:24 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 67 yards to the WLU3, Marcus Brown return 22 yards to the WLU25 (Vince Drzal). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu25 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 06:06. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu25 | L.D. Crow pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu25 | L.D. Crow pass intercepted by Cor. Washington at the WLU34, Cor. Washington return 34 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:54. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu03 | PENALTY WLU offside 2 yards to the WLU1. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 50, West Liberty 24 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 65 yards to the WLU5, Brandon Brown return 3 yards to the WLU8 (Kevin Williams). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu08 | WEST LIBERTY drive start at 05:43. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu08 | Brandon Davis rush for 2 yards to the WLU10 (Kevin Wiley). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Wlu10 | Brandon Davis rush for 10 yards to the WLU20, 1ST DOWN WLU (Kevin Wiley). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Ben Rogers pass complete to Tristen Devers for 5 yards to the WLU25 (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 2-5 | at Wlu25 | Brandon Davis rush for no gain to the WLU25 (Robert Hayes;Nic Tolson). |
| Wlu | 3-5 | at Wlu25 | Ben Rogers pass incomplete (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 4-5 | at Wlu25 | Griffin Yocum punt 40 yards to the SHEP35, Cor. Washington return 30 yards to the WLU35 (T.J. Lesniewski). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:54 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:49. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | Wm. McKenzie rush for 5 yards to the WLU30 (Lukas Turley). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu30 | Kevin Williams rush for 13 yards to the WLU17, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Kevin Williams rush for 3 yards to the WLU14 (Ryan Hughes). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu14 | Kevin Williams rush for 1 yard to the WLU13 (Bryan Spruill). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Wlu13 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:49 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Shepherd University 50, West Liberty 24 |