| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep35 | Change of possession, WLU ball on WLU35, 1st and 10. |
| | | Rickey Wilson kickoff 64 yards to the SHEP1, Will. McKenzie return 16 yards to the SHEP17 (D'An. Muhammed). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | SHEPHERD drive start at 14:52. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete (Nick Augustyn). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep17 | Bobby Cooper rush for 8 yards to the SHEP25 (Nate Maleski). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep25 | Allen Cross rush for no gain to the SHEP25 (Nate Maleski;Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 4-2 | at Shep25 | Troy McNeill punt 46 yards to the WLU29, fair catch by Isiah Moody. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 13:26. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 1 yard to the WLU30 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu30 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Hak. Cartwright (Levi Barber). |
| Wlu | 3-9 | at Wlu30 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete (Levi Barber). |
| Wlu | 4-9 | at Wlu30 | Griff Yocum punt 41 yards to the SHEP29, DJ Scott return 8 yards to the SHEP37 (TJ Lesniewski;Marc. Shumacher), PENALTY SHEP illegal block (Phillip Rhoden) 14 yards to the SHEP23, 1st and 10, SHEP ball on SHEP23. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:51 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep23 | SHEPHERD drive start at 12:35. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep23 | Bobby Cooper pass intercepted by Marco Ricchetti at the SHEP48, Marco Ricchetti return 42 yards to the SHEP6, Rod White for 6 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:15. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| | | Josh Wilson kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 7, Shepherd 0 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 60 yards to the SHEP5, Will. McKenzie return 32 yards to the SHEP37 (Darrell Stanley). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | SHEPHERD drive start at 12:08. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | Allen Cross rush for 1 yard to the SHEP38 (Rod White), PENALTY WLU personal foul (Marquis Bradley) 16 yards to the WLU46, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu46 | 1st and 10. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu46 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Larry Lowe for loss of 1 yard to the WLU47 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 2-11 | at Wlu47 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to John Frick for 30 yards to the WLU17, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti;Pierre Blake). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Allen Cross rush for 4 yards to the WLU13 (Marquis Bradley;Rod White). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Wlu13 | Allen Cross rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU15 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-8 | at Wlu15 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Will. McKenzie for 1 yard to the WLU14 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 4-7 | at Wlu14 | Ryan Earls field goal attempt from 31 GOOD, clock 08:38. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 7, Shepherd 3 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 49 yards, TOP 03:30 |
| | | Ryan Earls kickoff 55 yards to the WLU10, Dominic Cooper return 20 yards to the WLU30 (Keron Costen). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 08:32. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Gavin Hutchison. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu30 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 2 yards to the WLU32 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Wlu32 | PENALTY WLU false start (Dino Herrera) 5 yards to the WLU27. |
| Wlu | 3-13 | at Wlu27 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Kenj. Trueblood for 2 yards to the WLU29 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 4-11 | at Wlu29 | PENALTY WLU false start (Rod White) 5 yards to the WLU24. |
| Wlu | 4-16 | at Wlu24 | Griff Yocum punt 42 yards to the SHEP34, DJ Scott return 5 yards to the SHEP39 (Marc. Shumacher;Mike Jefferson). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep39 | SHEPHERD drive start at 06:35. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep39 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Larry Lowe for 19 yards to the WLU42, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu42 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 5 yards to the WLU37 (Kyle Agustin;Andrew Faraimo). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu37 | Jihad Rasheed rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU38 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Wlu38 | PENALTY SHEP false start (Sean Hull) 5 yards to the WLU43. |
| Shep | 3-11 | at Wlu43 | Bobby Cooper rush for 6 yards to the WLU37 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 4-5 | at Wlu37 | Troy McNeill punt 34 yards to the WLU3, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 24 yards, TOP 02:53 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu03 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 03:42. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu03 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 1 yard to the WLU4 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu04 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Tristen Devers for 13 yards to the WLU17, 1ST DOWN WLU (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Tristen Devers. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu17 | Ben Rogers pass complete to Dominic Cooper for 56 yards to the SHEP27, 1ST DOWN WLU (David Carter). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep27 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Marvin Murray (Phillip Rhoden). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep27 | Brand.Schroeder pass incomplete to Darrell Stanley. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Shep27 | PENALTY WLU delay of game (Dylan Lagarde) 5 yards to the SHEP32. |
| Wlu | 3-15 | at Shep32 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Isiah Moody for 12 yards to the SHEP20 (Dominic Tolson). |
| Wlu | 4-3 | at Shep20 | Jeff Hoak field goal attempt from 37 GOOD, clock 01:54. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 10, Shepherd 3 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 77 yards, TOP 01:48 |
| | | Rickey Wilson kickoff 65 yards to the SHEP0, touchback. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | SHEPHERD drive start at 01:54. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | Dalton Boyd rush for 52 yards to the WLU28, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Andrew Faraimo). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Allen Cross rush for 5 yards to the WLU23 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu23 | Bobby Cooper rush for 2 yards to the WLU21 (David Huggins;Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 3-3 | at Wlu21 | Allen Cross rush for 2 yards to the WLU19 (Marco Ricchetti;David Huggins). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 61 yards, TOP 04:34 |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 10, Shepherd 3 |
| Shep | 4-1 | at Wlu19 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Shep | 4-1 | at Wlu19 | Bobby Cooper rush for 2 yards to the WLU17, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Rod White). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Allen Cross rush for 4 yards to the WLU13 (Kyle Agustin;Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Wlu13 | Allen Cross rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU14 (Rod White), PENALTY WLU personal foul (Andrew Faraimo) 7 yards to the WLU7, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu07 | 1st and 7. |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu07 | Allen Cross rush for no gain to the WLU7 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-G | at Wlu07 | Bobby Cooper rush for 6 yards to the WLU1 (Nick Augustyn;Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 3-G | at Wlu01 | Mike Haynes rush for 1 yard to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:20. |
| | | Ryan Earls kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd 10, West Liberty Univ. 10 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 80 yards, TOP 04:34 |
| | | Ryan Earls kickoff 65 yards to the WLU0, Isiah Moody return 20 yards to the WLU20 (Phillip Rhoden;Keron Costen). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 12:14. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Hak. Cartwright for 61 yards to the SHEP19, 1ST DOWN WLU (David Carter;Dontre. Kelley). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep19 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep19 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 19 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:40. |
| | | Jeff Hoak kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 17, Shepherd 10 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 80 yards, TOP 00:34 |
| | | Rickey Wilson kickoff 60 yards to the SHEP5, Will. McKenzie return 19 yards to the SHEP24 (Darrell Stanley;Marc. Shumacher). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep24 | SHEPHERD drive start at 11:31. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep24 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 7 yards to the SHEP31 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-3 | at Shep31 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 1 yard to the SHEP32 (Brian Spruill). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep32 | Bobby Cooper rush for loss of 4 yards to the SHEP28. |
| Shep | 4-6 | at Shep28 | Troy McNeill punt 49 yards to the WLU23, Isiah Moody return 7 yards to the WLU30, fumble forced by Mike Haynes, fumble by Isiah Moody recovered by SHEP Jordan Domenico at WLU31. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu31 | SHEPHERD drive start at 09:30. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu31 | Will. McKenzie rush for 8 yards to the WLU23 (Nick Augustyn), PENALTY SHEP holding (Jonathan Hammer) 10 yards to the WLU33. |
| Shep | 1-12 | at Wlu33 | 1st and 12. |
| Shep | 1-12 | at Wlu33 | Bobby Cooper rush for 1 yard to the WLU32, out-of-bounds (Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 2-11 | at Wlu32 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to John Frick for 9 yards to the WLU23 (Kyle Agustin;Jov. Johnson). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Wlu23 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Mike Haynes. |
| Shep | 4-2 | at Wlu23 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Mike Haynes for 2 yards to the WLU21, fumble forced by Rod White, fumble by Mike Haynes recovered by WLU Kyle Agustin at WLU18. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu18 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 07:41. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu18 | Darrell Stanley rush for 2 yards to the WLU20 (Dontre. Kelley). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Wlu20 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Wlu20 | Dylan Lagarde sacked for loss of 10 yards to the WLU10 (Nick Pugh). |
| Wlu | 4-18 | at Wlu10 | Griff Yocum punt 37 yards to the WLU47, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 8 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu47 | SHEPHERD drive start at 06:06. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu47 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Robert Byrd. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu47 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Robert Byrd for 5 yards to the WLU42 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu42 | Bobby Cooper sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WLU48 (Nick Augustyn). |
| Shep | 4-11 | at Wlu48 | PENALTY SHEP false start (Luke Baxter) 5 yards to the SHEP47. |
| Shep | 4-16 | at Shep47 | Troy McNeill punt 41 yards to the WLU12, fair catch by Isiah Moody. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu12 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 04:26. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu12 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Dominic Cooper for 3 yards to the WLU15 (Levi Barber). |
| Wlu | 2-7 | at Wlu15 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Dominic Cooper for 3 yards to the WLU18 (Levi Barber;Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Wlu18 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Isiah Moody. |
| Wlu | 4-4 | at Wlu18 | Griff Yocum punt 45 yards to the SHEP37, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | SHEPHERD drive start at 03:04. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Larry Lowe for 27 yards to the WLU36, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 3 yards to the WLU33 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu33 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 2 yards to the WLU31 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu31 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Larry Lowe (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 4-5 | at Wlu31 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Jihad Rasheed for 2 yards to the WLU29 (Rod White). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 34 yards, TOP 01:55 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 01:09. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 8 yards to the WLU37 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Wlu37 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Tristen Devers for 7 yards to the WLU44, 1ST DOWN WLU, PENALTY SHEP personal foul (Robert Hayes) 8 yards to the SHEP48. |
| Wlu | 1-2 | at Shep48 | 1st and 10. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep48 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Anth. Armstead for 7 yards to the SHEP41 (Dontre. Kelley). |
| Wlu | 2-3 | at Shep41 | Timeout West Liberty Univ., clock 00:22. |
| Wlu | 2-3 | at Shep41 | Dylan Lagarde sacked for loss of 13 yards to the WLU46 (Levi Barber), fumble by Dylan Lagarde recovered by WLU Kenj. Trueblood at WLU46 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 3-16 | at Wlu46 | WLU ball on WLU48. |
| Wlu | 3-16 | at Wlu48 | 3rd and 14. |
| Wlu | 3-14 | at Wlu48 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 2 yards to the 50 yardline (Shaneil Jenkins). |
| Wlu | 4-12 | at Wlu50 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 19 yards, TOP 01:09 |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 17, Shepherd 10 |
| Wlu | 4-12 | at Wlu50 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 4-12 | at Wlu50 | Change of possession, SHEP ball on SHEP35, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 19 yards, TOP 01:09 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep35 | SHEPHERD drive start at 15:00. |
| | | Ryan Earls kickoff 55 yards to the WLU10, Justin Black return 9 yards to the WLU19, fumble forced by Bernard Wolley, fumble by Justin Black recovered by SHEP Dontre. Kelley at WLU28. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | SHEPHERD drive start at 14:52. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Allen Cross rush for 2 yards to the WLU26 (Marquis Bradley;Leon. Redding). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu26 | Will. McKenzie rush for 3 yards to the WLU23 (Jov. Johnson). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu23 | Allen Cross rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU24 (Andrew Faraimo;Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 4-6 | at Wlu24 | Ryan Earls field goal attempt from 41 MISSED - wide left, spot at WLU24, clock 13:11. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu24 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 13:11. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu24 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for no gain to the WLU24 (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu24 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Brand.Schroeder for 16 yards to the WLU40, 1ST DOWN WLU (Dominic Tolson). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Hak. Cartwright for 8 yards to the WLU48 (Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Wlu48 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for loss of 5 yards to the WLU43 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Wlu43 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Darrell Stanley. |
| Wlu | 4-7 | at Wlu43 | Griff Yocum punt 47 yards to the SHEP10, fair catch by DJ Scott. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 19 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep10 | SHEPHERD drive start at 10:44. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep10 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 5 yards to the SHEP15 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Shep15 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 6 yards to the SHEP21, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Rod White;Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep21 | Trae Tinsman at QB for Shepherd. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep21 | Jihad Rasheed rush for 5 yards to the SHEP26 (Andrew Faraimo;Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Shep26 | Trae Tinsman pass incomplete to Will. McKenzie. |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Shep26 | Trae Tinsman pass incomplete to Will. McKenzie. |
| Shep | 4-5 | at Shep26 | Troy McNeill punt 47 yards to the WLU27, fair catch by Isiah Moody. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 16 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu27 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 09:01. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu27 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Brand.Schroeder. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu27 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Anth. Armstead for 10 yards to the WLU37, 1ST DOWN WLU (Levi Barber). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu37 | 3rd and 1. |
| Wlu | 3-1 | at Wlu37 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Tristen Devers for 5 yards to the WLU42, 1ST DOWN WLU (Dontre. Kelley). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu42 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Tristen Devers. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu42 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Brand.Schroeder. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Wlu42 | Dylan Lagarde pass intercepted by Keon Robinson at the SHEP17, Keon Robinson return 0 yards to the SHEP17. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 15 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | SHEPHERD drive start at 07:24. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep17 | Trae Tinsman pass complete to Dalton Boyd for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP16 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 2-11 | at Shep16 | Trae Tinsman pass incomplete to Trevor Turner. |
| Shep | 3-11 | at Shep16 | Trae Tinsman pass complete to Robert Byrd for 7 yards to the SHEP23 (Justin Black). |
| Shep | 4-4 | at Shep23 | Troy McNeill punt 37 yards to the WLU40, fair catch by Isiah Moody. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 05:59. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Brand.Schroeder for 10 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WLU (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu50 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 1 yard to the SHEP49 (Dominic Tolson). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Shep49 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Brand.Schroeder. |
| Wlu | 3-9 | at Shep49 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Darrell Stanley for 4 yards to the SHEP45 (Shaneil Jenkins). |
| Wlu | 4-5 | at Shep45 | Griff Yocum punt 40 yards to the SHEP5, DJ Scott return 1 yards to the SHEP6, fumble forced by Omar Crawford, fumble by DJ Scott recovered by SHEP DJ Scott at SHEP1. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 15 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep01 | SHEPHERD drive start at 04:29, SHEP ball on SHEP1. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep01 | Allen Cross rush for 2 yards to the SHEP3 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep03 | Allen Cross rush for no gain to the SHEP3 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 3-8 | at Shep03 | Trae Tinsman rush for 22 yards to the SHEP25, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Jov. Johnson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep25 | Allen Cross rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHEP23 (Quinton Sifford). |
| Shep | 2-12 | at Shep23 | Trae Tinsman pass complete to Dalton Boyd for 3 yards to the SHEP26 (Marco Ricchetti;Rod White). |
| Shep | 3-9 | at Shep26 | Trae Tinsman pass incomplete to Will. McKenzie (Leon. Redding). |
| Shep | 4-9 | at Shep26 | Troy McNeill punt 46 yards to the WLU28, fair catch by Isiah Moody. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 25 yards, TOP 03:15 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 01:14. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for 3 yards to the WLU31 (Keon Robinson;Bryan Blue). |
| Wlu | 2-7 | at Wlu31 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Tristen Devers for 53 yards to the SHEP16, 1ST DOWN WLU (Phillip Rhoden). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep16 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Brand.Schroeder (David Carter). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep16 | Isiah Moody rush for 6 yards to the SHEP10 (Bryan Blue). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 62 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 17, Shepherd 10 |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Shep10 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Shep10 | Dylan Lagarde sacked for loss of 11 yards to the SHEP21 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 4-15 | at Shep21 | Jeff Hoak field goal attempt from 38 GOOD, PENALTY WLU false start (Jake Turley) 53 yards to the WLU26, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 4-68 | at Wlu26 | Jeff Hoak field goal attempt from 43 MISSED - wide left, spot at SHEP26, clock 14:10. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep26 | SHEPHERD drive start at 14:10. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep26 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Will. McKenzie for 11 yards to the SHEP37, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Will. McKenzie (Andrew Faraimo). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Billy Brown. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper at QB for Shepherd. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass intercepted by Jov. Johnson at the WLU41, Jov. Johnson return 7 yards to the WLU48. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 11 yards, TOP 00:38 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu48 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 13:32. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu48 | Kenj. Trueblood rush for loss of 3 yards to the WLU45 (Howard Jones). |
| Wlu | 2-13 | at Wlu45 | Isiah Moody rush for 9 yards to the SHEP46 (Nick Pugh;Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Shep46 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Tristen Devers for 12 yards to the SHEP34, 1ST DOWN WLU (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep34 | Isiah Moody rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHEP36 (Shaneil Jenkins). |
| Wlu | 2-12 | at Shep36 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Anth. Armstead for 7 yards to the SHEP29 (Levi Barber;Shaneil Jenkins). |
| Wlu | 3-5 | at Shep29 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Tristen Devers (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 4-5 | at Shep29 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Isiah Moody for 9 yards to the SHEP20, 1ST DOWN WLU (Nick Pugh). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep20 | Isiah Moody rush for no gain to the SHEP20, fumble forced by Bryan Blue, fumble by Isiah Moody recovered by SHEP Keon Robinson at SHEP19. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 33 yards, TOP 03:29 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep19 | SHEPHERD drive start at 10:03. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep19 | Allen Cross rush for 6 yards to the SHEP25 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep25 | Allen Cross rush for 2 yards to the SHEP27 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep27 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Allen Cross for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP26 (Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 4-3 | at Shep26 | Troy McNeill punt 45 yards to the WLU29, Hak. Cartwright return 20 yards to the WLU49 (Larry Lowe), PENALTY SHEP personal foul (Larry Lowe) 15 yards to the SHEP36, 1st and 10, WLU ball on SHEP36. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 02:11 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep36 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 07:52. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep36 | Dirone McBride rush for no gain to the SHEP36 (Shaneil Jenkins). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep36 | Dylan Lagarde pass complete to Dominic Cooper for 8 yards to the SHEP28 (Shaneil Jenkins), PENALTY WLU holding (Darrell Stanley) 9 yards to the SHEP45, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 2-19 | at Shep45 | Dylan Lagarde sacked for loss of 9 yards to the WLU46 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 3-28 | at Wlu46 | Dylan Lagarde pass incomplete to Dirone McBride. |
| Wlu | 4-28 | at Wlu46 | Griff Yocum punt 43 yards to the SHEP11, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 18 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep11 | SHEPHERD drive start at 05:59. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep11 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Jihad Rasheed for 4 yards to the SHEP15 (Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Shep15 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Larry Lowe. |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Shep15 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Jihad Rasheed for 22 yards to the SHEP37, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep37 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to John Frick for 9 yards to the SHEP46 (Marco Ricchetti). |
| Shep | 2-1 | at Shep46 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Will. McKenzie for 5 yards to the WLU49, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu49 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Billy Brown. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu49 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Billy Brown for 2 yards to the WLU47 (Marquis Bradley). |
| Shep | 3-8 | at Wlu47 | Bobby Cooper rush for 8 yards to the WLU39 (Mike Jefferson), PENALTY SHEP holding (Isaiah Shelton) 9 yards to the SHEP44, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 3-17 | at Shep44 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Jihad Rasheed for 4 yards to the SHEP48 (Kyle Agustin). |
| Shep | 4-13 | at Shep48 | Troy McNeill punt 44 yards to the WLU8, out-of-bounds, PENALTY SHEP illegal participation 5 yards to the WLU13, 1st and 10, WLU ball on WLU13. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 37 yards, TOP 03:38 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu13 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 02:21. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu13 | Isiah Moody rush for 1 yard to the WLU14 (Robert Hayes). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu14 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 02:17. |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu14 | Isiah Moody rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU12 (Howard Jones;Xavier Tyler). |
| Wlu | 3-11 | at Wlu12 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 02:13. |
| Wlu | 3-11 | at Wlu12 | Isiah Moody rush for loss of 3 yards to the WLU9 (Xavier Tyler). |
| Wlu | 4-14 | at Wlu09 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 02:08. |
| Wlu | 4-14 | at Wlu09 | Griff Yocum punt 32 yards to the WLU41, DJ Scott return 7 yards to the WLU34 (TJ Lesniewski). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:22 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu34 | SHEPHERD drive start at 01:59. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu34 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Larry Lowe for 19 yards to the WLU15, 1ST DOWN SHEP, out-of-bounds. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu15 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Larry Lowe (Rod White). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu15 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Larry Lowe. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu15 | Bobby Cooper pass incomplete to Larry Lowe, PENALTY SHEP intentional grounding (Bobby Cooper) 13 yards to the WLU28, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 3-23 | at Wlu28 | Bobby Cooper pass complete to Billy Brown for 28 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:33. |
| | | Ryan Earls kick attempt failed. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 17, Shepherd 16 |
| Shep | 1-G | at Shep35 | Timeout West Liberty Univ., clock 01:33. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 34 yards, TOP 00:26 |
| | | Ryan Earls kickoff 14 yards to the SHEP49, Marco Ricchetti return 0 yards to the SHEP49. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep49 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 01:31. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep49 | TEAM rush for loss of 3 yards to the WLU48. |
| Wlu | 2-13 | at Wlu48 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU46. |
| Wlu | 3-15 | at Wlu46 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU44. |
| Wlu | 4-17 | at Wlu44 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 17, Shepherd 16 |